California family courts · Judges · Appeal recordsGet Pro
The Family Bench
How family court judges across California fare when their rulings are appealed, county by county, plus a full deep dive on San Diego: every sitting family judge, former judges, and campaign money. Built only from public records, each one linked.
Keeping the house in a divorce? See what a buyout would take.
Who used to hear Vista family cases. These judicial officers sat in a North County family department, or ruled on North County family cases that were appealed, between 2019 and 2026. Their appeals still matter: their orders stay in effect, and several now hear civil cases in the same building.
Also named on single or shared orders in these appeals: Margo Lewis Hoy (retired 2021, Central family supervising judge), Cynthia A. Freeland (now Dept. 27, civil), Enrique E. Camarena (now South County), Christine K. Goldsmith (retired, sitting by assignment), and Tilisha T. Martin (adoption; now Juvenile).
What the records show so far. None of the Vista family judges has a campaign committee in the county's online filing system. Central, East, and South County judges have not been checked yet; Judge Meyerowitz (El Cajon) ran a contested 2024 race and is first on that list. Most were appointed by the Governor and later ran unopposed, so many never raised money at all. The attorney money in North County judicial races runs mainly through outside committees.
Outside committee · attorney-sponsored
Family First PAC, sponsored by the San Diego Family Law Bar Association
Spent in the March 2024 Superior Court race for Seat 41 (Jodi Cleesattle vs. Brian Erickson). Erickson now sits in Vista Dept. 14, criminal arraignments, not family. Its donor schedules are the clearest public record of family law attorneys funding judicial races.
Donor list: not yet extracted19 filings, 2022 – 2026
Form
What it is
Period
Filed
Source: San Diego County Registrar of Voters, CampaignDocs eRetrieval. Form 460s list every contributor of $100 or more, with name and employer.
Other outside spenders in county judicial races
Committee
Race
Election
Deputy Sheriffs' Association of San Diego County PAC
Seat 43
3/5/2024
Encinitas and North Coast Democratic Club
Seat 41
3/5/2024
Family First PAC (SD Family Law Bar Assn.)
Seat 41
3/5/2024
San Diego Police Officers Association PAC
Seats 31 & 32
6/2/2026
Still to pull
Family First PAC Form 460 contributor schedules (2022 – 2024 and 2026).
Paper campaign statements for Judges Mertsoc and Summers from their 2024 races. These require a records request to the Registrar of Voters, (858) 505-7265.
Cross-match of PAC donors against attorneys of record in the appeals listed under Judges.
Divorce home buyout estimator
Can you keep the house?
To keep the family home, the spouse who stays usually refinances or borrows against it to pay the other spouse their share of the equity. Enter your numbers to see roughly what that takes. Nothing you type leaves your device.
Example values shown. Replace them with yours. The settlement or court order sets the actual buyout amount.
Common ways to fund a buyout
Refinance into your name. Pays off the joint mortgage and the spouse's equity in one new loan, and removes your ex from the debt. Conventional, FHA and VA programs each have their own limits.
Keep your current low-rate mortgage and add a second loan. A HELOC or home-equity loan can fund the buyout without giving up a low first-mortgage rate. The lender may still require the ex-spouse to be released from the first mortgage.
Non-QM, for complex income. Self-employed, commission, or bank-statement income that standard lenders struggle with.
Home equity investment. Cash for a share of the home's future value, with no monthly payment. It costs more over time, so compare it carefully.
Timing matters. Support you receive may count as income once it is court-ordered and documented, and most lenders want the signed settlement or judgment before closing.
Before you talk to lenders
Get quotes from at least two or three lenders, and compare the total cost, not only the rate.
Ask each one how your ex will be released from the current mortgage. Removing someone from a deed does not remove them from the loan.
Bring your settlement draft or court order. Lenders size the buyout from it.
Estimates only. Not a loan offer, rate quote, or financial, legal, or tax advice. This site is not a lender and does not refer you to one.
Your account
You're using the free version
What's free and what's Pro
Free: every judge and county, outcome counts, odds on appeal, rosters, the buyout calculator, and your options guide. One judge's full record is open as a sample.
Pro: the full record behind every appeal: what was decided, why it was reversed or upheld, whether the appellant had a lawyer, and the link to the opinion. Plus spreadsheet (CSV) exports and new appeals added automatically every day.
Already a Pro member?
Enter the email you paid with and we'll send you a sign-in link.
Payments are processed by Stripe. Cancel any time from your account. Information from public court records; not legal advice. Records are a sample of appealed rulings, not a prediction of how any case will go.
Before your hearing
Make a record you can appeal
Many family appeals in this data failed because there was no transcript of the hearing, so the Court of Appeal could not review what happened. Many California courts do not supply a court reporter for family hearings. Ask the clerk early whether one will be present. If not, you can hire a certified shorthand reporter. If you have a fee waiver, you can ask the court for an official reporter at no cost (Jameson v. Desta, 2018).
Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.104
The appeal deadline is short
A notice of appeal is generally due 60 days after the clerk or the other side serves notice of the order or judgment, and never later than 180 days after it is entered. Missing it ends the appeal.
These are the tools a party has when assigned to a judge. Deadlines are strict. This page is general information, not legal advice; confirm with a family law attorney or the North County Family Law Facilitator.
Code Civ. Proc. § 170.6
One free challenge to the assigned judge
Each side may remove one judge without proving bias, by filing a peremptory challenge. For a reassignment, it is due within 15 days after notice of the new judge, or within 15 days after a party's first appearance if they had not yet appeared. Once used, it is gone for the case.
Code Civ. Proc. § 170.1(a)(9)
Mandatory removal over $1,500
A judge must step aside if, in the last six years (or the two years after), they received a campaign contribution over $1,500 from a party or a lawyer in the case. This is why the donor lists matter: they can be checked against opposing counsel.
Cal. Code of Judicial Ethics, Canon 3E(2)(b)
Disclosure of smaller contributions
Judges must disclose on the record contributions above the $100 reporting threshold from a party or lawyer appearing before them, even when removal is not required. A party may then move to disqualify.
Code Civ. Proc. § 170.3 · Commission on Judicial Performance
Bias complaints
A statement of disqualification for cause can be filed at any time with specific facts. Separate from the case, anyone can file a complaint with the Commission on Judicial Performance. In Marriage of Ghazi and Richard, the Court of Appeal rejected bias claims that lacked record support, so documentation matters.
How the appeal record was built
Scanned every Fourth District, Division One opinion currently posted by the California courts (about 270), then searched CourtListener's archive for each judge's name in the caption.
For former judges, collected about 250 San Diego family appeals decided January 2022 to October 2026 and kept the ones with North County case numbers. Appeals decided in 2019 – 2021 are not yet included, so judges who left before 2022 are under-counted.
Former judges' assignments come from the court's reassignment notices (2022 – 2026) and its current judge directory.
Central and East County rosters are current as of October 9–10, 2026. The court's South County listing was last updated July 21, 2026, so it may be out of date.
Central, East, and South County appeals shown so far come from a first pass of each opinion's caption. Issue summaries and whether the appellant had a lawyer are still being added; those appeals are left out of the odds panel until they are.
Each opinion was read for case number, issue, outcome, and whether the appellant had a lawyer. North County family case numbers end in N (for example 24FL003865N).
Statewide: every opinion the California Courts of Appeal currently post (about 2,500 across all six districts) was scanned. Unpublished opinions stay listed for roughly 60 days and published ones for longer, so the statewide set is mostly 2025 – 2026. Each family case was read by hand for county, trial judge, outcome, and whether the appellant had a lawyer.
Some districts (often the First, Third, and Sixth) do not name the trial judge in unpublished opinions. Those appeals are listed under "Judge not named in the opinion."
San Diego data current as of October 11, 2026; statewide data as of October 14, 2026. New statewide appeals are added automatically every day; those entries are marked "added automatically" until reviewed.
Read the numbers carefully
Only a small share of rulings are ever appealed, so this is not a full picture of any judge.
The appeals court affirms most family orders, because it defers to the trial judge on facts. A reversal is a meaningful signal; a lone affirmance says less.
Several self-represented appeals were affirmed because the appellant supplied no transcript. That reflects the record, not necessarily the merits.
Judges who joined the bench in 2023 – 2024 have had little time to build a record. No appeal found is not the same as no problems.
A campaign contribution shows who funded a judge. On its own it does not show that money changed a ruling.